Svētku priekšvakarā varam noslēgt mūsu “Gooogle lietošanas izcilības” konkursu un noteikt uzvarētāju. Atgādināšu, ka konkursa jautājums tika formulēts šādi:
Norādiet uz valsti (-īm), kuras:
- Sauszemes spēkos nav nevienas vismaz par 70% nokomplektētas regulārā karaspēka (PD un/vai OMD) vienības vismaz vienas kājnieku brigādes vai viena pulka lielumā;
- Valdības kontrolē ir paramilitārās vienības, kurās kopā piedalās mazāk par 0,5% no valsts iedzīvotāju skaita.
Ienākošos priekšlikumus par atbilstību jautājumu kritērijiem es pārbaudīju pēc respektabla Military Balance 2016 izdevuma. No tālākās izvērtēšanas “lidoja ārā” valstis , kurām nav paramilitāro spēku (ZS).
Ceru skaidrs, ka konkursa mērķis bija atrast valsti ar aizsardzības konstrukciju, kas līdzinātos mūsējai – nepilna sastāva (kā kaujas vienība neeksitējoša) regulāro spēku kājnieku brigāde un ne pārāk liela Zemessardze (ņemot par pamatu oficiālos ZS personāla datus tie ir 0,5% no LV pilsoņu skaita, īstenībā mazāk).
Tā kā atbildi sākotnēji nezināju, pašam bija interesanti un pamācoši uzzināt, ka lieli paramilitārie spēki nabadzīgās valstīs ir retums, ja nav nav normālas armijas, nav arī lielas zemessardzes. Pareizi āfrikāņu diktatori spriež, iedosi tautai ieročus, tā uzreiz apvērsumus sāks plānot, tātad vispirms jābūt kārtīgai regulārai armijai, kas ir labi lielāka par Zemessardzi. Lielas zemessardzes raksturīgas tieši Eiropas un Ziemeļamērikas valstīm vai samērā bagātām valstīm, kas skaidrojams ar pilsoniskās sabiedrības attīstību un vispārējo likumpaklausību.
Nejautājiet man kādēļ tabulā apskatītas tiešī šīs valstis, nevis citas un vēl šādas un tādas. Ko konkursanti iesūtīja, to arī vērtēju. Plānos ir salīdzināt 3B armijas savā starpā, bet tas ir pavisam cits stāsts.
valsts | Military balance 2016 dati | Piezīmes |
Trinidad and Tobago | Population 1,222,363
The Trinidad and Tobago Defence Force remains focusedon providing border and maritime security, and counternarcotics tasks. In support of the country’s ongoing fight with crime, the army is intended to play a greater, moreintegrated role. The army’s receipt of light utility vehiclesfrom China in 2015 provides an indicator of the closerdiplomatic and military ties between the countries, whichhas included other procurement and training provisions.Renewed efforts to re-equip the coast guard have resulted in an order for 12 new patrol vessels, of three different classes,from Dutch firm Damen. Trinidad and Tobago was one ofthe first regional states to publish a cyber strategy, in 2012,which noted potential defence vulnerabilities arising from compromised critical national infrastructure. ACTIVE 4,050 (Army 3,000 Coast Guard 1,050) Army ε3,000 SPECIAL FORCES 1 SF unit MANOEUVRE Light 2 inf bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 engr bn COMBAT SERVICE SUPPORT 1 log bn |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Fiji | Population 909,389
The role of Fiji’s armed forces is to guarantee the security of the nation, though they have been involved in several coups since the 1980s, the most recent in 2007, and civil military relations remain a concern. Though small, the armed forces have regularly taken part in international peacekeeping tasks. Defence relations with its traditional security partners – Australia, New Zealand and the US were re-established at the end of 2014, after they were suspended in the wake of the 2007 coup. During this period, Fiji looked more to China and Russia, and the extent to which Fiji will revert – if at all – to the previous security relationship is unclear. ACTIVE 3,500 (Army 3,200 Navy 300) RESERVE ε6,000 Army 3,200 (incl 300 recalled reserves) SPECIAL FORCES 1 spec ops coy MANOEUVRE Light 3 inf bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 arty bty 1 engr bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 log bn Reserves 6,000
|
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Monte negro | Population 647,073
Montenegro’s armed forces are small and primarily organised around the army, with few air and naval assets. The force is supported by a significant paramilitary organisation. Capability remains focused on internal security and limited support to international peacekeeping. Montenegro is committed to joining NATO and has begun reforms in order to facilitate this. Some indications suggest Montenegro is a candidate for accession during NATO’s July 2016 summit in Warsaw and the NATO Military committee visited the country in October 2015 as part of this assessment. However, reforms have been slow, with only a small part of the defence budget spent on modernisation. ACTIVE 2,080 (Army 1,500 Navy 350 Air Force 230) Paramilitary 10,100 Army 1,500 SPECIAL FORCES 1 SF bde MANOEUVRE Reconnaissance 1 recce coy Light 1 mot inf bde (1 SF coy, 2 inf regt (1 inf bn, 1 mtn bn), 1 arty bty, 1 cbt spt coy, 1 CBRN pl, 1 sig pl) |
ZS=1,55%
2 bde (SF, InF) |
Brunei | Population 429,646
The Royal Brunei Armed Forces are an important source of employment in the oil-rich state. While professional and well trained, their limited size means they could offer little resistance on their own to a determined aggressor.While the defence budget was reduced in 2015, this arose from the transfer of the bulk of procurement funding to the Ministry of Finance, and lower oil and gas prices are putting pressure on Brunei’s defence-planning targets. The sultanate has long-established defence relations with the UK and Singapore, and the UK and Brunei have renewed for another five years a long-standing agreement to station UK troops in the sultanate. Brunei continues to deploy small peacekeeping contingents, under Malaysian command, to Lebanon (UNIFIL) and the southern Philippines (IMT). ACTIVE 7,000 (Army 4,900 Navy 1,000 Air 1,100) Paramilitary 2,250 RESERVE 700 (Army 700) Army 4,900 MANOEUVRE Light 3 inf bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 cbt spt bn (1 armd recce sqn, 1 engr sqn) Reserves 700 Light 1 inf bn |
ZS=0,52%
Atsevišķie inf bn |
Lesotho | Population 1,947,701
Lesotho’s small armed forces are charged with protecting territorial integrity and sovereignty, although cohesionhas suffered following an attempted military coup in September 2014. That prompted South Africa to deploy 140members of its Police Service in late 2014. South Africa,in effect, acts as a security guarantor; Lesotho containssignificant water resources. Continued political instability throughout 2015, notably the killing in mid-year of aformer army commander, led South Africa to send a fact finding mission, and SADC to organise a Commission ofInquiry. Security-sector reform was being urged by year end. ACTIVE 2,000 (Army 2,000) Army ε2,000 MANOEUVRE Reconnaissance 1 recce coy Light 7 inf coy Aviation 1 sqn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 arty bty(-) 1 spt coy (with mor) |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Guinea-Bissau | Population 1,726,170
The armed forces have often played a direct role in domestic politics. Narcotics trafficking remains a substantialproblem that the armed forces have so far been unable to tackle. The parlous state of the economy limits any ability to replace its ageing inventory of mainly Soviet-era equipment. Previous attempts at security-sector reform have largely been unsuccessful, and long-term international support is necessary for future attempts to gain traction. ACTIVE 4,450 (Army 4,000 Navy 350 Air 100) Paramilitary 2,000 Army ε4,000 (numbers reducing) MANOEUVRE Reconnaissance 1 recce coy Armoured 1 armd bn (sqn) Light 5 inf bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 arty bn 1 engr coy |
ZS=0,11%
Atsevišķie inf bn |
Gabon | Population 1,705,336
Gabon’s small armed forces are reasonably well equipped for their size, and there is sufficient airlift to ensure mobility within the country and even a limited capability to project power into its near abroad both by sea and air. The country has benefited from the long-term presence of French troops acting as a security guarantor, while oil revenues have hitherto allowed the government to support, in regional terms, capable armed forces. There is regular training with international partners. Military medicine is well regarded. Gabon contributed a field hospital to the ECCAS Loango 2014 exercise, and engaged in field medical training with US forces in 2015. Gabon hosted US AFRICOM’s 2015 Central Accord interoperability exercise. ACTIVE 4,700 (Army 3,200 Navy 500 Air 1,000) Paramilitary 2,000 ORGANISATIONS BY SERVICE Army 3,200 MANOEUVRE Light 1 (Republican Guard) gd gp (bn) (1 armd/recce coy, 3 inf coy, 1 arty bty, 1 ADA bty) 8 inf coy Air Manoeuvre 1 cdo/AB coy COMBAT SUPPORT 1 engr coy |
ZS= 0,12%
Atsevišķie inf bn |
Benin | Population 10,448,647
The country’s small armed forces are mainly focused on border and internal security, and combating illicit traffick – ing. However, maritime security remains an area of concern, in light of continuing piracy in the Gulf of Guinea. Benin’s small navy has been trying to bolster its anti-piracy capability by acquiring further high-speed craft. The air force has a limited number of light transport aircraft and helicopters for intra-theatre airlift, and is also developing a surveillance role. The army and national police have received training from US personnel to enhance their border surveillance capacity. France is heavily involved in training assistance; in 2015 this included medical and combat training for the armyand diver training for the navy. ACTIVE 6,950 (Army 6,500 Navy 200 Air 250) Paramilitary 2,500 Army 6,500 MANOEUVRE Armoured 2 armd sqn Light 1 (rapid reaction) mot inf bn 8 inf bn Air Manoeuvre 1 AB bn COMBAT SUPPORT 2 arty bn 1 engr bn 1 sigs bn COMBAT SERVICE SUPPORT 1 log bn 1 spt bn |
ZS=0,02%
Atsevišķie inf bn |
Liberia | Population 4,195,666
The development of the Liberian armed forces has beenunderpinned by US support for almost the past decade, although the UN’s UNMIL mission is still required as a stabilisation force 11 years after it was established. There is no domestic airlift capacity; this will have hindered attempts to respond to the recent Ebola outbreak, which constituted a major challenge for the developing local security forces. ACTIVE 2,050 (Army 2,000, Coast Guard 50) Army 2,000 MANOEUVRE Light 1 (23rd) inf bde with (2 inf bn, 1 engr coy, 1 MP coy) COMBAT SERVICE SUPPORT 1 trg unit (forming) |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Guyana | Population 735,554
The country has a limited military capability based on the Guyana Defence Force. The GDF’s main tasks are territorial integrity, assisting the civil power and contributing to economic development, and it also undertakes paramilitary and policing tasks. Long-running border issues with Venezuela returned to the spotlight following the declaration by Caracas of maritime defence zones, one of which included Guyanese waters claimed by Venezuela and which had seen a significant oil discovery in 2015. Guyana has officer-training agreements and military ties with both Brazil and China, and participates in the Tradewinds exercise programme. ACTIVE 3,400 (Army 3,000 Navy 200 Air 200) RESERVE 670 (Army 500 Navy 170) Army 900 SPECIAL FORCES 1 SF coy MANOUEVRE Light 1 inf bn Other 1 (Presidential) gd bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 arty coy 1 (spt wpn) cbt spt coy 1 engr coy
|
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Equatorial Guinea | Population 740,743
The country’s armed forces are dominated by the army, with smaller naval and air components. The army’s primary role is internal security, and there is only limited ability for power projection. There has been significant naval investment in recent years, including both equipment and onshore infrastructure at Malabo and Bata. Maritime-security concerns in the Gulf of Guinea have resulted in increased emphasis on bolstering a limited coastal-patrol capacity, with new offshore-patrol vessels commissioned, and the nation’s forces taking part in international exercises, ACTIVE 1,320 (Army 1,100 Navy 120 Air 100) Army 1,100 MANOEUVRE Light 3 inf bn(-)
|
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Papua New Guinea | Population 6,672,429
Papua New Guinea has small, lightly equipped armed forces that in effect constitute an internal security force only. Core tasks noted in the country’s 2013 defence white paper include defending the state; civil-emergency assis tance; nation building; and meeting international obligations. However, the document also said that ‘our defence capabilities have deteriorated to the extent that we havealarming gaps in our land, air and maritime borders’.There is some concern over the possibility of fighting byseparatists in the neighbouring Indonesian territory of Irian Jaya spilling across the western border. The white paper called for defence assets and capability to be rebuilt,and for the overall force size to increase to 5,000 (including 1,000 reservists) by 2017. The extent to which this ambitious plan has begun to be implemented is unclear. Papua New Guinea’s main security partner is Australia, with which its armed forces also exercise. ACTIVE 1,900 (Army 1,600 Maritime Element 200Air 100) Army ε1,600 MANOEUVRE Light 2 inf bn COMBAT SUPPORT 1 engr bn 1 EOD unit 1 sigs sqn |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Gambia | Population 1,967,709
Maritime security and human trafficking are security concerns. A National Maritime Security Committee was inaugurated in 2015. The country has a small army supported by air and marine units. Its forces have been deployed in support of UN missions, and have received training assistance from the US. ACTIVE 800 (Army 800) Gambian National Army 800 MANOEUVRE Light 2 inf bn Other 1 (Presidential Guard) gd coy COMBAT SUPPORT 1 engr sqn |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Vatikāns | 1. Valsts armijā ir tikai 101 karavīrs. 2. Paramilitāros veidojumos (policija u.tml.) ir 0% valsts iedzīvotāju, jo tos veido citu valstu iedzīvotāji. |
Nav ZS/paramil. |
Zviedrija | Population 9,723,809
The armed forces remain configured for territorial defence, the equipment and capabilities of all three services reflecting this task. National defence became a topic of debate during the Russian annexation of Crimea in 2014 and has increased since the escalation in Russian military activity in the Baltic. Anxiety over Swedish preparedness has led to greater cooperation with NATO and NORDEFCO partners, as well as further deliberation over Swedish membership of the Alliance. Future capabilities will depend on the delivery of key procurements, including Gripen JAS- 39E combat aircraft and A26 submarines. The purchase of 60 new Gripen aircraft was approved by Sweden’s parliament in 2013, and a similar announcement was made in 2015 on A26 and Gotland-class submarine upgrades. The government announced an increase to planned defence spending between 2016 and 2020 in response to security concerns, with funds being spent on modernising shipsand re-deploying troops on the strategically important island of Gotland. ACTIVE 29,750 (Army 6,850 Navy 2,100 Air 2,700 Other 18,100) Paramilitary 21,200 Army 6,850 COMMAND 2 bde HQ MANOEUVRE Reconnaissance 1 recce bn Armoured 3 armd coy Mechanised 5 mech bn Light 1 mot inf bn 1 lt inf bn Air Manoeuvre 1 AB bn Other 1 sy bn COMBAT SUPPORT 2 arty bn 2 AD bn 2 engr bn 2 MP coy 1 CBRN coy COMBAT SERVICE SUPPORT 1 tpt coy Reserves FORCES BY ROLE MANOEUVRE Other 40 Home Guard bn |
ZS=0,21%
2 kājnieku pulki |
Vērtēšana:
Valsts /kritērijs | Inf bde/rgt <1 | Paramil <0,5% popul | Vērtējums |
Montenegro | 2 bde | 1,55% | 3.vieta |
Brunei | 0 | 0,52% | 1.vieta |
Zviedrija | 2 rgt | 0,21% | 2.vieta |
Secinājumi: LV aizsardzības modelis (SzS kontekstā) ir vistuvāk Brunejai un Zviedrijai. Tomēr Zviedrija droši atkrīt uz 2.vietu, jo tās aizsardzības modelis piedzīvo re-reformu un atgriežas pie Aukstā kara risinājumiem, kas attālina to no LV NBS konstrukcijas, kas no 2006.gada bez mayor izmaiņām.
Atgriežoties pie Military balance rezumējuma par Brunejas sultanāta armiju (skat.augstāk) līdzības ar NBS vienkārši uzprasās, lai tās pieminētu:
– “professional and well trained” gluži kā mūsu PD;
– “their limited size means they could offer little resistance on their own to a determined aggressor” pie zīlnieces var neiet, tā arī ir .
– “sultanate has long-established defence relations with the UK and Singapore” vienīgā atšķirība no NBS, ka ar Singapūru mūsu sultanātam tās attiecības pagaidām nav tik labas. Bet tas taču tikai laika jautājums.
– “3 inf bn” tas vispār 1:1 ar NBS SzS brigādi;
Un pats galvenais:
-“Brunei have renewed for another five years a long-standing agreement to station UK troops in the sultanate” Ak redz, kur tas sultāna drošības stūrakmens paslēpts, to sargā briti (gurkhas) slēdzot līgumu uz 5 gadiem. Neviens neatceras uz cik gadiem mums ir līgums ar Kanādu?
Nevaru neatzīmēt, ka Bruneja arī izmanto CVR(T), bet krietni mazākā skaitā kā LV, jo Brunejai ir arī normāli riteņu bruņutransportieri.
Tāpat kā latvieši, brunejieši nevar dzīvot bez parādēm, mums ir ko mācīties 🙂
Vajadzētu papētīt to sultanāta aizsardzības modeli tuvāk, bet nu jau ir 4 a.m. un šogad man vēl jāpaspēj pagulēt zem eglītes.
Ņemot vērā augstākminēto un to, ka 100% trāpījuma kriterijos šorez nav, par uzvarētājiem tiek paslidināti
- vieta (jau kuro reizi!) “Info” par Bruneju;
- vieta “MG1” par Zviedriju
- vieta “Pipars” par Montenegro
- speciāla balva no manis personīgi misteram “Konkursa Pieteikums” par domāšanu ārpus kastes.
Uzvarētājiem (katram no 4) uzsaukšu 2 x kausus alus jebkurā Vecrīgas krogā (man patīk beļģu, bet neuzstāju). Kausa izmērs atkarīgs no vietas topā, bet ne mazāks par 0,33l 🙂
Katrs no augstākminētajiem uzvarētājiem kungiem aicināts atsaukties uz e-pastu līdz janvāra beigām ar konkrētu priekšlikumu no viņa puses, kuru PIEKTDIENU pēc 17:01 mēs varam tikties, lai pārrunātu LV līdzību ar sultanātu, pie reizes atprečojot tiesības un izpildot saistības.
Paldies par dalību konkursā un laimīgu Jauno gadu!
PS Lai ieguldītais darbs neietu zudumā zemāk “MG1” pamatojums par Zviedriju:
[..] 1. Atbildi sāku meklēt ar 2.jautājumu.
Zviedrijas iedzīvotāju skaits noapaļojot 9 miljoni (kopā ar migrantiem un “bēgļiem” varētu būt tuvu 10 miljoniem). Zviedrijas nacionālajā gvardē pašlaik ir apmēram 22 000 karavīri. 2001.gadā to bija 2 reizes vairāk – uztaisīja finanšu “konsolidāciju” un skaitu samazināja. 22 000 salīdzinot ar 9 miljoniem ir 0,24%. Tātad – Zviedrijas paramilitārajās vienībās piedalās mazāk nekā 0,5% no valsts iedzīvotāju skaita.
- Atbilde par sauszemes spēku brigādēm vai pulkiem, kuru sastāvs nav nokomplektēts par 70%. Kopš 2010.gadā Zviedrijā nolikvidēja OMD – pašlaik Zviedrijas armijā jeb sauszemes spēkos dienē ~6000 karavīru.
http://www.armedforces.co.uk/Europeandefence/edcountries/countrysweden.htm Kā saprotams no šī raksta, tad Zviedrijas armija plāno tikai 2016.gadā izveidot pirmo brigādi. No internetā atrodamās informācijas – brigāde nav izveidota.
“As currently structured, the organization includes two brigade headquarters and eight maneuver battalions: five mechanized, one motorized infantry, one light infantry and one amphibious.
“There had been discussions that a brigade is an ‘old’ organization and we have to look at some other ones,” Brännström said, “but that’s not true. It’s very clear that we think that the brigade is the best organization for ground operations.
“And the conclusion of that is that, first of all, we should build the first brigade in about 2016. Then, we should carry on and, as we get new people in the organization, to fill out the unit and have another brigade about 2019.”
http://www.editiondigital.net/article/Swedish_Army_Restructures,_Reduces/1904968/242037/article.html
No vikipēdijas bildītes redzama Zviedrijas armijas uzbūve – ar pulkiem un to sastāvā esošajiem bataljoniem. https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/28/Swedish_Army_Rapid_Reaction_Organisation_Units.png
Visnopietnākais no sastāva ir “Norrbotten Regiment” – 2 mehanizētie bataljoni un 1 jēgeru bataljons. Bet, diemžēl, skaitliskais sastāvs ir sekojošs: “As of 2016, the Norrbotten Regiment employs 475 professional officers, 415 full-time soldiers, 529 part-time soldiers, 112 civilians and 661 reserve officers”.
Parādās 529 daļēja laika karavīri un 661 rezerves virsnieks. Reālo vienības “kodolu veido” 890 karavīri. ~900 karavīri nav vērtējami kā par 70% noformēts pulks vai brigāde. Precīzāka informācija ir zviedru lapā: http://www.forsvarsmakten.se/sv/organisation/norrbottens-regemente-i-19/ [..]
Nekas tā vēl vairāk neuzlabo garīgo pus 8 no rīta (kad apskatījos) kā uzvara konkursā šādā dienā 🙂
“jau kuro reizi!” – tikai otro no 4 (?) 🙂 Vajag arī pakonkurēt par kādu nomināciju ar mums labi zināmo komentu čempionu, tikai es savā disciplīnā 😀
Laimīgu Jauno gadu! 😉
Hehe, Tu par mani vai noklīdušo jobtech’u 😀 ?
Lai nu kā, dzer ar prātu, Tev tomēr vismaz litrs a to i divi jāizrauj un pēc tam vēl pa kādma un vēl un vēl un beigās kā Šveikā 😀 !
Kā sacīt jāsaka, kurš gan cits 😀
Protams, kur nu bez prāta..līdz 5. glāzei vēl jūt… 😀
3.vieta “Pipars” par Montenegro- jēēē, tas ir vairāk kā vinnēt momentloterijā rubli! 😀
es labprāt pievienotos dzert alu ar pārējiem konkursa uzvarētājiem, ja viņiem nav iebildumu! esmu diezgan elastīgs laika un vietas ziņā, ja datums iepriekš zināms, jo labā kompānijā alu dzert var arī šķūnī!
Visiem priecīgu Nākošo!
Paldies. Aizsūtīšu tev laiku un vietu uz e-pastu.
Nu pag, tad jau var mini-DF pie alus kausa un ķiploku grauzdiņiem 😉 !
Sure. Katrs bundzinieks var piebiedroties šobrīd orientējoši 6.janv pēc darba. Detaļas epastā.
OK, apskatīšos 😀 !
Ā, pag, nav nekāda e-pasta.
Ne tik strauji 😊
Tikmēr re….82% estipoisu gatavi aizstāvēties ar ieročiem rokās.
Re ku promo klips pat uztaisīts.
Gribēji likt justies slikti? Pirmo reizi sanāca.
Neķer kreņķi!
Neaizmirsti, ka šamējie ir lieli PR speciālisti. Jāapskatās metodoloģiju, kā nonāca pie šādiem cipariem.